Problem

For defence contractors, the Invitation to Negotiate (ITN) or Invitation to Tender (ITT) arrives infrequently. When it does, the demands are exacting: a comprehensive pricing submission and risk model that must be auditable by the MoD’s Cost Assurance and Analysis Service (CAAS), aligned with Appropriate, Attributable, and Reasonable (AAR) guidance, and contractable as a Qualifying Defence Contract (QDC) through the Single Source Regulations Office (SSRO). These are not requirements that most commercial functions are routinely equipped to meet.

A submarine programme was approaching the transition into its next pricing period — the delivery phase — and the contractor faced exactly this challenge. The commercial team did not have the in-house knowledge or resources to produce a cost estimate and risk model at the standard public sector scrutiny demands. The expertise to build a submission that would hold up under CAAS audit, within the timeline and requirements of the ITN, was not available internally.

Challenge

The technical challenge was compounded by a commercial one. The contractor’s commercial team were risk-averse: their natural position was to avoid carrying pricing risk, and to seek cost-plus or estimate-based fee terms. The MoD’s position, shaped by the SSRO’s findings that Option E and F arrangements are a cause of cost growth and difficulty in managing budgets, was the opposite — a firm preference for Option A or Option B, fixed or firm price contracting, to maintain a stable order book.

This was the contractor’s first opportunity to contract at Option A/B, and the conditions for doing so were not in place. There was no auditable estimate. There was no compliant risk model. There was no clear understanding of what risk they were actually being asked to carry. Without that foundation, the commercial team could neither quantify their exposure with confidence nor make the case — internally or to the customer — for an informed position on pricing.

Solution

Kaleido supported the bid manager and commercial team across all pricing-related matters, providing the analytical backbone the ITN response required.

Stakeholder Engagement and Cost Modelling

We ran structured workshops with over ten stakeholder groups, drawing in knowledge from engineering, commercial, and supply chain functions that rarely contribute directly to a pricing submission. From that process, we compiled a multi-stakeholder cost data model that built estimates from first principles against the ITN’s requirements — grounded in the direct input of the people who understood the work, not assumptions derived from previous contracts.

Basis of Estimate and Compliance

A Basis of Estimate document was developed to the standard required for CAAS audit: structured, traceable, and compliant with AAR guidance. Kaleido uplifted its existing templates specifically for the demands of this submission, ensuring that the work product was not just internally consistent, but fit for the scrutiny of the SSRO and contractable as a QDC.

Risk Analysis and Communication

A cost risk analysis model was developed alongside the estimate, calibrated to meet AAR guidance and SSRO contractual requirements. Crucially, Kaleido did not leave the risk analysis as a technical output. We translated it into clear, accessible communication for the contractor’s senior stakeholders — giving them the understanding of their true exposure they needed to commit, with confidence, to an Option A/B position for the first time.

The result was a commercially advantageous submission: compliant, auditable, and structured to deliver enhanced profitability through the contractor’s first-ever Option A/B contract.