Problem

A client organisation that had recently undergone significant transformation and moved into public ownership was facing demand for nuclear project delivery at a scale not seen in a generation. Across fissile and conventional programmes — new build and nuclear refits — the portfolio was expanding rapidly on multiple fronts simultaneously. Multiple projects required funding sanctioning at various stages of development, from Outline Business Case through Full Business Case to project close-out.

The organisation had no Suitably Qualified and Experienced Personnel (SQEP) in-house with the estimating, risk management, and risk modelling expertise that these investment appraisals demanded. Contractors and Managed Service Providers operating across construction and infrastructure were similarly under-resourced in these disciplines. The client was being asked to advance — and defend — major investment decisions without an independent analytical capability to support them.

Challenge

Without client-side SQEP capability, the organisation was exposed on several fronts at once. It had no credible basis for challenging or assuring the estimates and risk models submitted by contractors. It could not develop independent estimates aligned to the standards that CAAS and public sector scrutiny bodies require. And it lacked the technical authority to counter the bias that tends to accumulate in contractor submissions over time: cost and schedule positions that had become embedded and were presented as given, rather than as estimates to be tested.

Compounding this was the breadth and simultaneity of the task. Multiple concurrent investment appraisals at different maturity stages, across different programmes, each with distinct technical requirements and stakeholder dynamics — all needing to be progressed at the same time. The risk was not simply that individual projects would be inadequately assured, but that a portfolio of investment decisions would be made on a systematically weak evidential base.

Solution

Kaleido augmented the client’s resource with specialist estimating and risk modelling expertise, acting as the client-side analytical capability across several concurrent investment appraisals between 2022 and 2025. The work spanned Outline Business Cases, Full Business Cases, and mid-project Review Notes across a portfolio with combined outturn costs exceeding £10bn.

Assurance and Independent Estimating

We assured contractor tender returns, restructured evaluation frameworks where needed, and developed independent client-side estimates built to CAAS standards. This gave the client a credible analytical counterpoint — not to obstruct, but to enable properly informed challenge and ensure that sanctioning decisions were grounded in evidence rather than in contractor-presented assumptions.

Exposing True Exposure

Cost and schedule risk analysis was used to measure what the programmes were actually carrying: the risks and uncertainties that had been absorbed into baselines, or simply left unmodelled. Where contractor positions reflected optimism rather than analysis, we made that visible and communicated it clearly. Data Readiness Levels were deployed as a shared language with scrutiny committees — a structured, transparent mechanism for validating the basis of an estimate, exposing the limitations of stagnant sub-projects or work packages, and building the case for realistic sanction decisions on strategy and scope.

Communicating to Decision-Makers

Trust was built through effective storytelling. Investment Appraisal Committees needed to understand the risk picture, not merely receive it. Kaleido translated complex quantitative analysis into narratives that aligned senior stakeholders on true exposure and equipped the client to go into scrutiny with confidence. The outcome was the successful sanctioning of over £1bn of capital spend from Full Business Case to Full Operating Capability and project close-out.

Conclusion

This engagement demonstrates how Kaleido provides the intelligent client capability that organisations need when internal SQEP resource cannot be recruited or developed at pace. In environments where investment decisions carry public accountability and scrutiny, independent analytical authority is not a luxury — it is a requirement. By acting as that authority across a complex, multi-programme nuclear portfolio, Kaleido enabled realistic, defensible investment appraisals and helped the client communicate with confidence to the committees that matter most.

What Our Clients Said

“Kaleido were pivotal in delivering a Major Project Business Case for investment appraisal under government scrutiny during extreme market volatility and affordability challenges. Their expertise and ability to translate complex information at every level were exceptional.”

Project Director

“Cost assurance of industry estimates required speed and immediate actions we could not compromise on. Kaleido’s analytical rigour elevated the entire process. Their work was both comprehensive and accessible, enabling faster, more confident decisions with complete integrity.”

Project Controls Manager

“Complex cost modelling during economic uncertainty demanded both technical expertise and clear stakeholder communication. Kaleido consistently exceeded expectations, surfacing critical sensitivities and influencing key decisions with clarity. It felt like we gained the capability of an entire consultancy team from one individual.”

Senior Project Manager